US privatized food safety inspections graded: Fail
Third-party audits for food safety likened to mail-order diploma mills for education.
by Michael Moss and Andrew Martin, The New York Times
March 5, 209 — When food industry giants like Kellogg want to ensure that American consumers are being protected from contaminated products, they rely on private inspectors like Eugene A Hatfield. So last spring Hatfield headed to the Peanut Corp. of America plant in southwest Georgia to make sure its chopped nuts, paste and peanut butter were safe to use in foods like granola bars and ice cream.
The peanut company, though, knew in advance that Hatfield was coming. He had less than a day to check the entire plant, which processed several million pounds of peanuts a month.
Hatfield, 66, an expert in fresh produce, was not aware that peanuts were readily susceptible to salmonella poisoning - which he was not required to test for anyway. And while Hatfield was inspecting the plant to reassure Kellogg and other food companies of its suitability as a supplier, the Peanut Corp. was paying him for his efforts.
"The overall food safety level of this facility was considered to be: SUPERIOR," he concluded in his March 27, 2008, report for his employer, the American Institute of Baking, which performs audits for major food companies. A copy of the audit was obtained by The New York Times.
Federal investigators later discovered that the dilapidated plant was ravaged by salmonella and had been shipping tainted peanuts and paste for at least nine months. But they were too late to prevent what has become one of the nation's worst known outbreaks of food-borne disease in recent years, in which nine are believed to have died and an estimated 22,500 were sickened.
With government inspectors overwhelmed by the task of guarding the nation's food supply, the job of monitoring food plants has in large part fallen to an army of private auditors like Hatfield. And the problems go well beyond peanuts. .
To read further, please click on the link below. . .
Privatization vs. Public Values Frame
Industry is responsible enough to be cautious / Industry is as responsible as is required by law
Links and sources
Food safety problems slip by auditors, by Michael Moss and Andrew Martin, The New York Times, March 5 2009, via The Day
Food Problems Elude Private Inspectors, by Michael Moss and Andrew Martin, The New York Times, March 5 2009
Posted: March 12, 2009
Voices of privatization
Feedback and dialogue
Public Values (PublicValues.ca) is a project of the Golden Lake Institute and the online publication StraightGoods.ca