Back-to-work legislation "put on Parliament's red-eye bullet train"
Government meddling sabotaged CP Rail-Teamster negotiations.
OTTAWA, ON, May 30, 2012: Back-to-work legislation designed to end a CP Rail strike and get freight moving won't passed in the Senate until Thursday at the earliest, despite its overnight passage in the House of Commons.
MPs voted just before 1:30 a.m. to pass Bill C-39, ordering 4,800 Canadian Pacific engineers and conductors back to work after a weeklong strike.
Labour Minister Lisa Raitt said the labour dispute must end quickly because of the toll it's taking on the economy and the Harper government used its majority to force the legislation through the House of Commons in a single day.
There are no indications the Liberal minority in the upper chamber intends to obstruct the bill, but Senate rules normally require 48 hours' notice to debate legislation.
Even if every senator consents to speeding up the process, the back-to-work bill is not likely to be voted upon until sometime Thursday afternoon, when it can quickly get royal assent and become law.
| || ||"There is no incentive for the parties to negotiate in good faith if they know the government will step in." |
Raitt has said she wants the trains running again by Thursday, but both the company and the Teamsters union — representing striking workers — say re-starting the vast transportation network will take time.
On Tuesday night, back-to-work legislation was put on Parliament's equivalent of a red-eye bullet train.
The Conservative government used its majority to limit debate, setting in motion a series of overnight votes that saw the bill passed early Wednesday morning.
"The economy's being affected, there's no question about that at all," Labour Minister Lisa Raitt told the Commons during question period Tuesday.
"It's getting very tight for people who rely upon CP Rail and the transit of their goods and the receipt of their materials," Raitt said.
"And as such, for the greater good of the economy, we feel that the time has come where the negotiations have stopped, the work stoppage continues and we really do need to make sure that CP Rail gets working on Thursday."
But the union, backed by Opposition MPs, said the government's quick threat to order 4,800 engineers and conductors back on the job shortly after the strike began last Wednesday short-circuited talks at the bargaining table.
"When will these Conservatives figure out that workers are the backbone of the economy?" charged NDP critic Irene Mathyssen, noting a cut to the workers' pension fund "is at the heart of this dispute."
Mathyssen accused CP Rail, which posted a profit of $570 million last year, of going after the pension plan to increase its profitability and said the Harper government is enabling the company.
"Why are Conservatives always picking winners and losers and why is it that workers' pensions are always under attack?"
Raitt pointed out that the back-to-work legislation calls for a government-appointed arbitrator to resolve outstanding differences within 90 days and "doesn't pre-determined any issue."
"We are acting on the side of the Canadian economy and the general Canadian public interest," said Raitt.
"We're not the ones taking sides," added the minister. "I don't think the Opposition can say the same thing."
It's the third time in the past year the Harper government has moved to legislate an end to a labour dispute and critics say the government is tilting the field in favour of employers and against workers.
NDP Leader Tom Mulcair opened the evening debate by saying the Conservatives have sent employers a clear signal with the repeated legislated back-to-work threats at Canada Post, Air Canada and now CP Rail.
"It sends a terrible message that legislative settlement is the new labour relations norm in Canada," said Mulcair. "There is no incentive for the parties to negotiate in good faith if they know the government will step in."
About 100 CP Rail workers, members of the Teamsters Canada Rail Conference, protested on the steps below Parliament's Peace Tower, where they met with a number of Liberal and NDP MPs.
Protesting employee Richard Moffat, president of a Teamsters local in Toronto and a locomotive engineer, said CP Rail is "asking for everything" and claimed the company has been aiming for an arbitrated settlement from the get-go.
"The back to work legislation puts us in arbitration — right where they want to be — by a Conservative-appointed arbitrator," said Moffat.
"And this all came from Lisa Raitt tipping her hand last week that she was going to order us back to work."
CP Rail countered Tuesday that "multiple reasonable and good faith offers" have been made to the unionized employees since talks began last October.
"The Teamsters pushed their members into an unnecessary work stoppage and have throughout the negotiations refused to minimize the impact on other affected CP employees, our customers and the Canadian economy," Peter Edward, the company's vice-president of human resources and industrial relations, said in a release.
Opposition MPs also complained that the government has used its majority to limit parliamentary debate 23 times since last May's election — but the government says that with CP freight traffic at a standstill and costing the economy half a billion dollars a week, time is of the essence.
The labour unrest comes amid front-office turmoil that saw CP's chief executive officer Fred Green and much of the old company board forced out by an investor revolt, led by a New York-based hedge fund, Pershing Square Capital Management LP.
Green, who was accused by Pershing principal Bill Ackman of running an under-performing company, walked away with an $18-million severance package.
Links and sources
CP Rail back-to-work bill slowed by Senate rules
Posted: May 31, 2012
Public Values (PublicValues.ca) is a project of the Golden Lake Institute and the online publication StraightGoods.ca